Identifying an Unknown Metal
Investigate single-displacement reactions and construct an evidence-based activity series.
Background Information
In a single-displacement reaction, a more reactive metal can transfer electrons to the ions of a less reactive metal. The solid metal is oxidized while the dissolved metal ions are reduced.
General form: M(s) + N2+(aq) → M2+(aq) + N(s), provided M is more reactive than N and both form 2+ ions.
Example: Zn(s) + CuSO₄(aq) → ZnSO₄(aq) + Cu(s).
Oxidation: Zn(s) → Zn²⁺(aq) + 2e⁻. Reduction: Cu²⁺(aq) + 2e⁻ → Cu(s).
For the metals used here, the reference activity order is Mg > Zn > Fe > Cu > Ag. A more reactive solid metal generally displaces ions of a less reactive metal. Visible evidence may include a metallic coating, changes in the appearance of the metal, or changes in solution colour. Not every real reaction produces a conspicuous change within a short observation period.
Metal ions may have different charges. For example, the balanced reaction between magnesium and silver nitrate is Mg(s) + 2AgNO₃(aq) → Mg(NO₃)₂(aq) + 2Ag(s).
Safety in a physical laboratory
Wear splash goggles and follow teacher directions. Silver nitrate can stain skin and is hazardous to aquatic life; metal salt solutions must be disposed of as instructed, not poured into drains without authorization.
Print or save the assignment, perform the virtual lab, record observations and complete your lab report.
Student Assignment
Research question: Which of five candidate metals is the unknown sample, based on its reactions with known metal-ion solutions?
- Generate an unknown sample. Its identity remains hidden until you submit a prediction.
- Test the unknown against at least four different metal-ion solutions; record the observations.
- Run at least three control tests with known metals to establish a comparison.
- Infer the unknown's relative position in the activity series, and identify it with supporting evidence.
- Write balanced molecular and net ionic equations for two reactions that occur, including oxidation and reduction half-reactions where applicable.
- Discuss at least two limitations of this model or experimental design.
Submission: Complete the Lab Report tab, including your prediction, evidence, calculations/equations and conclusion. Use Print / Save PDF to submit to your teacher.
Virtual Test Bench
Select a metal and a solution to begin.
No test performed
Identify Unknown X
The unknown is one of Mg, Zn, Fe, Cu, or Ag. Use your recorded observations to infer its identity.
Recorded Observations
| Trial | Metal strip | Ion solution | Reaction? | Observed evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No observations yet. | ||||
Reaction Frequency by Solution
Counts reflect the tests you performed, not intrinsic reaction rates.
Formal Laboratory Report
Purpose and Hypothesis
Variables and Procedure
Results
Your recorded trial table appears below when you print.
Analysis — Equations and Electron Transfer
Identification and Conclusion
Evaluation and Sources of Error
Your written responses and observations are saved in this browser. For a portable backup, download a JSON draft.
Teacher Resources
Learning goals: Analyze single-displacement reactions, distinguish oxidation from reduction, apply the activity series, and support conclusions with experimental evidence.
Suggested KTCA weighting: Knowledge 25%, Thinking 35%, Communication 20%, Application 20%.
Assessment: Check the number and diagnostic value of tests, accurate balanced equations, explicit comparison of positive and negative results, and quality of evaluation.
Reference activity order: Mg > Zn > Fe > Cu > Ag. A reaction is predicted when the solid metal is above the metal ion in this order. A metal placed in a solution containing its own ions shows no net single displacement.
Teaching note: Unknown X is randomly selected per new experiment; do not treat a student's chosen answer as proof without the observation table. This page is not a secure assessment environment and students can inspect client-side code.