Background Information
The law of conservation of mass states that matter is neither created nor destroyed during an ordinary chemical reaction. Atoms are rearranged into new substances, but the total mass of all substances remains constant in a closed system.
Closed system
A sealed container retains gases and other reaction products. The measured total mass before and after the reaction should remain the same, within measurement uncertainty.
Open system
Gas may escape into the surroundings. A balance measuring only the remaining container and contents can show a decrease, even though mass is conserved across the entire system and surroundings.
Example reaction
Vinegar contains acetic acid, which reacts with sodium bicarbonate (baking soda):
CH₃COOH + NaHCO₃ → CH₃COONa + H₂O + CO₂
Carbon dioxide gas can escape from an open vessel. In a sealed apparatus, the gas remains part of the measured mass.
Print or save the assignment, perform the virtual lab, record observations and complete your lab report.
Student Assignment
Question: How does the system boundary affect the measured mass during a reaction that produces a gas?
- Write a hypothesis predicting mass changes in an open and closed system.
- Choose the vinegar + baking soda reaction and run one trial with the container closed.
- Repeat with the container open, using the same starting quantities.
- Repeat both trials using a different reactant amount.
- Investigate a second reaction and compare the results.
- Record at least six trials, export data, and construct a conclusion using evidence.
Variables: Independent — system type (open/closed); dependent — measured mass change (g); controls — starting quantities, reaction type, scale resolution and measurement procedure.
Success criteria: Explain why an open system can show an apparent mass decrease without violating conservation of mass; identify what the balance measures.
Interactive Experiment
Choose conditions and run a reaction.
Data & Graphs
The graph shows measured mass change for each trial. Closed-system values should be approximately zero; open-system gas-producing reactions can show a negative change.
| Trial | Reaction | System | Batch (g) | Before (g) | After (g) | Δ mass (g) | Gas escaped (g) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No trials recorded yet. | |||||||
Student Lab Report
Responses are saved locally in this browser. Enter your name before exporting a draft.
Printing uses your browser's Save as PDF option. Data is not uploaded to WorksheetGalaxy.
Teacher Resources
Course: SNC2D · Chemistry: chemical reactions and conservation of mass.
Expected conceptual results
- Closed-system total mass remains constant, subject to balance resolution.
- Open-system measured mass decreases when a gas escapes beyond the measured boundary.
- Precipitation without gas loss shows little or no measured mass change in either system.
- More gas-generating reactant may increase gas production, but the simulator uses a simplified proportional relationship.
Assessment rubric (KTCA)
| Category | Weight | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Knowledge & Understanding | 25% | Correct explanation of conservation of mass and system boundaries |
| Thinking & Investigation | 30% | Controlled comparison, repeats, careful interpretation |
| Communication | 20% | Clear table, graph, units, scientific vocabulary |
| Application | 25% | Relates observations to gas escape and mass conservation |
Limitations
Numbers are deterministic educational estimates, not laboratory measurements. The gas yield is an illustrative model and not a stoichiometric prediction from specified concentrations. The simulation omits leakage, humidity, temperature, buoyancy, vessel deformation and experimental uncertainty beyond display resolution. It should not be used to predict pressure or to plan a real sealed reaction.
Extension
Ask students to draw a system boundary around the balance, container and surroundings. Explain how mass conservation applies to the larger boundary even when a balance reading falls.